Accessibility

Font size
Line height
Contrast
Other options
|

Special Feature on Musicians Who Fled in 1944: Pianist Hilja Saarne

In the autumn of 1944, around 80,000 people left Estonia due to the Red Army’s invasion. There has long been talk of the elite fleeing, but this notion has now been refuted. Nevertheless, a significant number of active cultural figures departed – among them, nearly two-thirds of professional performers and organisers of musical life. This meant that for some time, Soviet Estonia’s music scene had reduced capacity, at least in terms of human resources, and the musicians who had fled had to start anew in foreign conditions, not knowing if or when they could return home.

Among refugee musicians, the composer Eduard Tubin, the pianist Käbi Laretei, and the conductor Roman Toi are familiar to the broader public. Yet, there were hundreds of Estonian-origin performers and musical figures active in exile (according to Avo Hirvesoo’s calculation, in 1944, there were about 440 active musicians before the flight, of whom nearly 300 fled westwards). 1 Many of them were well-known to the local audience during independence. Still, by now most of them have been forgotten, partly because during the occupation, there was no free communication or exchange of information between Soviet Estonia and the Western world.

One such example is the pianist Hilja Saarne (1911–2001), who was well-known in the 1930s but disappeared from the view of Home Estonia after fleeing; her story offers a microhistorical perspective – her life path and professional activity also provide insight into larger historical events, and her fate resembles that of many of her contemporaries. Before the Soviet occupation, she had been an active soloist and chamber musician, and known to radio audiences for her tasteful performances on the State Broadcasting soloists’ programme.

Pianist Hilja Saarne’s concert activity, spanning more than half a century across two very different social contexts – before and after her flight in 1944 (in Estonia and Sweden, respectively) – illustrates how larger history is reflected even in smaller stories, including those of individuals. The Hilja Saarne personal archive (unindexed) at the Theatre and Music Museum reflects her professional journey, including repertoire, stage partners, and critics’ reception. As most of the materials are from her time in Sweden, valuable additions regarding her Estonian period can be found in digitised newspapers. Concert programmes, interviews, and reviews provide a basis for reflection on how forced relocation and adaptation to a new environment affected her musical life and identity. The archival holdings allow Saarne’s story to be viewed from both the perspective of broader adaptation and that of maintaining personal and artistic identity.

ESTONIAN ERA CONCERT ACTIVITY (1933-1944)

Hilja Saarne studied at the Higher Music School in Tartu and at the Tallinn Conservatoire in Artur Lemba’s piano class, which she completed in 1935. She furthered her studies in Budapest and Vienna, demonstrating her ambitions for professional development; alongside her freelance activity, Saarne took private lessons with Hans Höpfel. In the 1930s, in Estonia, concert life was vivacious, and Saarne was active both as a soloist and as an ensemble player. She was a frequent performer on the state broadcasting service (in total, she played on the radio 29 times in programmes of about half an hour), with her repertoire including both classical works (Beethoven, Liszt, Brahms) and works by Estonian composers, such as Artur Lemba. Saarne’s creative activity in Estonia was already focused on chamber music: she particularly enjoyed performing with other musicians, including well-known names such as Silvia Tobias and Dagmar Kokker. In the years before fleeing, Saarne also played a leading role in Haapsalu's cultural life, where she moved when her husband, Apollon Saarne, became director of the Lääne County Hospital.

Graduates of Artur Lemba’s piano class in 1935 (Saarne is in the front row, at the far right) 2

FLEEING AND ADAPTING IN SWEDEN

In 1944, the Saarne family fled to Sweden on the ship Triina. It was one of the last ships to leave Tallinn and, carrying nearly twice the permitted 250 people, was overcrowded. The music scores Hilja Saarne brought with her were left behind on shore because the ship was overloaded. After fleeing, women, children, and men were placed in separate camps, as was the case with the Saarne family. The whole family was reunited at the Neglinge refugee camp, where several other prominent figures were also gathered. There, Hilja Saarne was reunited with her colleagues from her Estonian period and collaborated with a wide range of creative intellectuals. In total, there were 64 residents in the camp, who together put together entertainment programmes performed in other refugee camps. The activities were funded by an organisation such as Hjälp Krigets Offer (Aid the Victims of War), and the performers called themselves Flyktingkonstnärerna (refugee artists). As one programme from such a tour shows, the plans were made to the minute, and at times, horse transport was even used for travel between camps.

Refugee Artists Tour Schedule

The transition from camp life to everyday life depended on the work opportunities available to refugees: for musicians and other cultural figures, it was more difficult, as only a few could continue professional work. The Swedish state created so-called archive work, which consisted of substitute activities for intellectuals. Still, only a few musicians were able to take it up (for example, the composer Eduard Tubin rewrote old scores in the archive of the Drottningholm Palace Theatre until his retirement).

Hilja Saarne was unable to take on such archive work. For the first six years, she lived in Stockholm, where she performed with other Estonians in various choral concerts as an ensemble member and as an accompanist to soloists, occasionally performing solo pieces herself; later, she settled permanently in Gothenburg, in western Sweden. While the Estonian community events in Stockholm provided some opportunity to maintain a professional form, they did not offer sufficient financial security or a creative outlet.

CONCERT ACTIVITY IN SWEDEN (1950-1999)

After moving to western Sweden, Saarne’s concert activity became more varied: she performed both at Estonian community events and at concerts for the general Swedish public. Her repertoire expanded to include Swedish composers and contemporary music. For decades, Saarne was one of the main pillars of cultural events at compatriots’ ceremonies and concerts in Gothenburg, where the Estonian community was considerably smaller than in Stockholm, but where the republic’s anniversaries were celebrated continuously, choirs were active, and literary-musical matinées were held. Important Estonian collaborators for Saarne while living in Gothenburg included, for example, the former Estonia Theatre soloists Milvi Laid and Ida Loo-Talvari. Over almost 50 years, Saarne performed at global Estonian (ESTO) festivals, Swedish-Estonian cultural days (Estival), and literary-musical evenings, the latter becoming a distinctive feature of Estonian cultural life in western Sweden.


Programme of a concert by the Estonian Mixed Choir in Stockholm, with Saarne appearing as a guest performer from Gothenburg

Although contributing to the Swedish-Estonian community was close to Saarne’s heart, her creative activity also shows that she integrated into the local music scene. Over the decades, she collaborated with 67 local performers and appeared in performances organised by various concert societies and associations, as well as by the state concert bureau (Rikskonserter). Her long-term ensemble partner was Guido Vecchi, concertmaster of the cello section of the Gothenburg Symphony Orchestra, with whom she gave 107 concerts. Their repertoire included classical works (Beethoven, Boccherini, Debussy) as well as Estonian composers such as Tubin and Kapp. Saarne occasionally brought Vecchi and other local performers to Estonian community events. She also performed with several internationally renowned singers (Dorothy Irving, Birgit Finnilä, and John Fleming), collaborations she regarded as the peak of her creative work.

SAARNE’S PRINT ON SWEDISH MUSIC LIFE AND HER MUSICIAN-PROFILE

Saarne recorded 53 programmes for Swedish Radio. Around half of the works she performed belonged to the field of contemporary music. She performed several new works, including politically critical compositions. Saarne’s playing was broadcast on Swedish radio as recently as 2022 – the trace of her music lives on longer than she did. Her pianism was described as masterful, sensitive, and flexible. Although she often remained in the background in chamber ensembles, critics recognised the quality of her playing.

Hilja Saarne regarded music as a matter of the soul, not a career. She preferred playing together with others, enjoying the rehearsal process and exchange of ideas. The peak of her creative activity came in the 1960s. Still, her performance activity continued until the end of her life – even after losing her musical perception (amusia resulting from a stroke), she continued practising, with her last concert programmes dating from 1999, only two years before her death.

Hilja Saarne’s life and work offer insight into how an artist shapes her identity within two very different social orders. Her story is a testament to the sustainability of Estonian musical culture in the diaspora, to professional adaptability (and the fact that the two are not mutually exclusive), and to the significance of a sense of cultural belonging.


1 Hirvesoo, Avo 1996. Kõik ilmalaanen laiali. Lugu eesti pagulasmuusikutest. Tallinn: AS Kupar.
2 Lippus, Virve 1997. Eesti pianistliku kultuuri kujunemine. Eesti muusikaloo toimetised 3. Tallinn: Eesti Muusikaakadeemia.
* In the opening photo, Hilja Saarne is the person on the far right. In 1970. Celebration of the anniversary of the Republic of Estonia at the Stockholm Concert Hall. Photo: EFA.656.0.409913