Accessibility

Font size
Line height
Contrast
Other options
|

A year-end reflection on how we received our inheritance

A few years ago, we decided at the Estonian History Museum to dedicate the 2025-2026 temporary exhibition to the history of Maarjamäe and its current stage of heritage conservation. In the exhibition You Have an Inheritance, we are wondering how we transitioned from creating things and places to recognising, investigating, and preserving them through popular initiatives, and then to state-organised heritage conservation. Fourteen monuments, like drops of water, mirror the world, telling the story of inheritance over the last century. From 12 interviews with heirs, investigators, and users, it becomes clear where the idea and organisation of heritage conservation are moving.

The first push to make the exhibition was the knowledge that on June 19, 2025, a hundred years had passed since the adoption of Estonia’s first heritage conservation law. Naturally, no law is ever adopted out of thin air; it always has a deeper meaning and a definite goal, for example, a policy that preserves or directs communal choices.


Go up on the wall of Uruk and walk around,

examine its foundation, inspect its brickwork thoroughly

Is not (even the core of) the brick structure made of kiln-fired brick,

And did not the Seven Sages themselves lay out their plans?

(The Epic of Gilgamesh, Tablet I, 18-21, XIII-XI c. BC, Electronic Edition by Wolf Carnahan, 1998, Translated by Maureen Gallery Kovacs.)

In the stories of the legendary Sumerian king Gilgamesh, the oldest epic preserved in writing, humans search for immortality. It was believed that everything good that humanity had, had come from inheriting the wisdom of the antediluvian people. Heritage conservation is engaged with humans’ natural urge to give meaning to who we are, where we come from, and why we are the way we are.

Cultural heritage is a value to the entire society, but its material aspect extends beyond common or national property to encompass private property as well. Therefore, restrictions imposed in the public interest must be enacted into law. A good legislator strives to strike a balance between an individual's responsibility and society's in legal acts. The laws that strike this balance have the potential to become genuine social agreements.

I have previously pondered time, space, and memory on the blog. This time, I will take into consideration the story of heritage appreciation.

 

IN SEARCH OF THE BEGINNING

The journey to the adoption of the Heritage Conservation Act in 1925 began a lot earlier, long before the establishment of the Republic of Estonia. But can we pinpoint precisely when the first step on this journey was taken? When did people start noticing the traces left by those before them, and which did they begin to treat as a value? What did an honest hunter-gatherer think about deforestation to establish fields and pastures?

Vepsian slash-and-burn farming in 1926. ERM Fk 609:38


What is referred to as the Neolithic Revolution in historical science is more accurately described as an evolution that lasted for centuries. The lifestyle and environment of people changed so gradually that perhaps it did not arouse anyone's anxiety. Or if it did, could we investigate it?


Subjects of divine right are things sacred and things religious. Sacred things are those consecrated to the gods above; religious, those devoted to the gods below. Sacred things can only become so with the authority of the people of Rome, by consecration in pursuance of a law or a decree of the senate. A religious thing becomes so by private will, when an individual buries a dead body in his own ground, provided the burial is his proper business. Sanctioned places are to a certain extent under divine dominion, such as city gates and city walls.

(The Institutes of Gaius. Translated by Edward Poste.) [i]


Gaius (lived in the 2nd century AD) was a Roman lawyer. The writers of one part of Justinianus’s influential legislature, Institutions, based their writing primarily on Gaius’s work (VI c. AD). Legislators in Europe relied on Justinianus’s legislature (later known as Corpus iuris civilis) since the Middle Ages. The division of Roman law into private and public law, along with the Roman legal principles that underpin it, form the basis of current law.


While Gaius was writing the referenced lines, the groups of people living on Estonian grounds, with whom we share a genetic code [ii], were building fenced graves for deceased community members.


Nõo Jaagupi enclosure grave. PäMu 716 F 2560:3


The graves were used for burials for a few centuries, and even later, to the edges of the graves or near them. [iii] The use of landscape was then surely already hierarchical, with some population centres dominating others. [iv] Most likely, every piece of land without forest was “on account” as property. It is interesting to consider whether our ancestors also pondered, as the Romans did, godly and religious matters, i.e., things and places not classified as private property.


What did a person living in Estonia think about during the 13th century, when large stone buildings (fortresses, monasteries, and churches) started appearing next to the foundations and wooden buildings? Legend has it that in many places, churches were built directly on the holy sites of the residents. Similarly, with the construction of almost every larger building comes a legend about someone destroying what was built during the day at night.


Haljala church is one of these places which is said to have been built on the holy grounds of the old Estonians.

ERM Fk 830:136


The first stone buildings, which, compared to the later ones, had relatively modest dimensions, still seemed significantly larger than the former residential buildings of the wealthiest chiefs. There were actually only a few of them, but the “spatial policy” of the conquerors was definitely designed to crush the self-perception of the conquered nation.


Roman view by an unknown artist. 19th century. AM 7361:17 G 1114


Bearing in mind that our beloved Rome has suffered significant decay and damage, because of the lack of an antique profession, whose task was to take care of city roads, streets, squares and for the maintenance and restoration of other public and private estates and buildings - and because some citizens of the city throw spoiled meat, bones, blood, and other decomposing waste into the streets and others occupy and corrupt public and saintly possessions for self-interest -, we decide to restore and re-establish this profession in all its antique glory and authority. Consequently, we allow him to:

1. Remove all defilements and violations that arise over time, non-litigiously, through direct measures.

2. Punish rebels and disturbances, and establish necessary repairs and restoration work.

3. Use all the rights and authority of his predecessors as they were in ancient Rome.

(Papal Ordinance of Pope Martin V, 31 March 1425 [v], Translated from Estonian by Marion Pilv)

The recreation of the profession of roadmasters - magistri viarum - in Rome, in 1425, is one of the first papal orders, where you can see the concern for inheritance, i.e. for the preservation of things important to the larger community, regardless of whether they are publicly or privately owned. [vi] Papal bulls followed from 1468 to 1474, which established a requirement for the preservation of art assets accumulated in churches. Did people in Estonia also apprehend that the church properties we had here in Maarjamaa were also somehow special? [vii] Could the replacement of square fortress towers with round ones, with the coming of gunpowder, or even more - the burying of city walls in earthworks - cause some of the residents to feel a quixotic fighting spirit or at least a defiance towards the changing of the world?

 

KING’S COMMAND

Significant intellectual and cultural shifts marked the early modern period. The Reformation, Industrial Revolution, and Enlightenment in the Western world, over time, transformed belief in God into belief in science, and gratitude for what we have into a culture of consumerism. Society was not the same anymore, but the basic human need - the want to know where we come from and who we are - did not change. With the crumbling of the religious vision, fading manners, customs, and taboos gave rise to state-organised heritage conservation.

The first heritage conservation act that concerned Estonia was enacted in the name of a young Swedish king, Karl XI, on 28 November 1666. The poster-manifesto stipulated a ban on the destruction of old castles, manors, stone fortresses, citadels, stone mounds, rune stones, as well as large, piled-up earthen mounds, family graves, and other similar structures on the king's and the country's land, and their taking under royal protection. Additionally, the law stipulated that anyone possessing old coins must inform the king. If similar antiquities were located on the original noble lands, then the king called the nobility to follow his example, threatening with disfavour otherwise. [viii] How powerful a punishment was disfavour? It was not limited to the denial of a dinner invitation but also caused significant societal and economic damage to the one who fell into disfavour.


At least one copy of Sweden’s first heritage conservation act has remained on our land and is housed at the University of Tartu's library. During the exhibition “You Have an Inheritance,” it can be viewed at Maarjamäe Palace.

Photo Vahur Lõhmus


The poster had to be sent to government officials and church ministers. The king’s command surely also got to the then overseas provinces. The earliest notice of Viking treasure found on Estonian grounds could be an indirect hint of the real-life application of the law. Namely, coins found in the village of Järise, Karuse parish, were quickly taken to Stockholm by the village’s ruler, Philip Belm, in 1685. [ix]

 

A LONG CENTURY OF SOCIALLY INTERPRETING HERITAGE

The Great Northern War put the development of “heritage protection” on hold, but did not destroy it. The intellectuals of Baltic Germany, captivated by the Enlightenment and the storm and rush of Romanticism, not only dealt with “their own heritage” - medieval fortresses, churches, and cities -but they also estophilically paid attention to the antiquities of the rural people. For example, Count Ludwig August Mellin mapped dozens of so-called peasant fortresses in his atlas [x] in the years 1791-1810.


The 19th century could boldly be named the century of valuing, interpreting, and describing heritage. Local and regional learned societies were established, whose members were, of course, primarily rural and urban intellectuals, pastors, townspeople, and nobles. Among them were also representatives of the rural population who had fought for university education (Estonians and Latvians), which ensured that heritage-themed ideas spread from one group to another. Presentations were given in associations, and research was published in proceedings; personal collections began to be transferred to societies, thus laying the foundation for museums.


Estonia’s national awakening also brought, among the rural population, the idea of seeking their roots. In 1888, Jakob Hurt published in Postimees a plea titled „Paar palwid Eesti ärksamaile poegadele ja tütardele“, in which he urged people to send him folklore, dialect examples, poems and songs, dances, and folk tales. Over 1,500 collectors have recorded tens of thousands of pages of Estonian spiritual heritage, on which research continues and from which inspiration is drawn.


Poster dedicated to Jakob Hurt. 1989. AM F158 10:218


In 1895, advised by Finnish archaeologists and drawing on Jakob Hurt’s collection work, Jaan Jung (1835-1900), a school teacher and avid archaeology enthusiast from Abja, proposed gathering common knowledge about tangible heritage. His plea was answered by over 500 people, who sent information about hundreds of antiquities, resulting in the first comprehensive list of cemeteries, stone tombs, fortresses, sacrificial sites, chapel hills, stone crosses, and other notable sites. Jung was able to publish some of these lists himself in two books titled Muinasaja teadus eestlaste maalt. After he died, the Estonian Literary Society continued its work; in its proceedings, part III of the series was published (1910). As the introduction for the book, Villem Reiman published the biography of an enormous enthusiast and noted to his and the people's praise: “Despite the praise of economic policy and materialism, there is still great noble treasure and capacity for enthusiasm hidden in the soul of the Estonian people, if there will be a lucky child, who can open the door of a secret chamber with a miracle flower.” [xi]


Jaan Jung, among other cultural figures.

Photos Heinrich Tiidemann AM 13813 F 11684:37


Despite private heritage conservation activities and expectations, tsarist power did not establish a substantially functioning heritage conservation organisation in the current Estonian territory until the end of its existence. However, the collection of ancient artefacts was already demanded in Peter the First's ukase. In 1826, Tsar Nikolai I obliged the governors to determine where and in what condition the remains of old castles and fortresses had been preserved. [xii] In the Baltic Provincial Act [xiii] issued in 1845, the official duty of Estonian plough judge, Livonian bridge judge and Courland hauptmann was submitting reports to the authorities about all the rare natural attractions, ancient monuments etc. of the region, but unfortunately, neither contemporary nor later researchers have highlighted this fact as an effective management of cultural and natural heritage.


Heinz Pirang described in his presentation at the Baltic Historians’ Days in 1912 how, at the beginning of the new century, the Baltic Germans tried to urge the central government to organise heritage conservation. Still, all their attempts failed because the existence of an inventory of monuments in need of protection was taken as a prerequisite. The question of who and when should have organised the list remained unresolved; they did not even reach agreement on the definition of a monument. An equally important obstacle was the formation of a national organisational structure. Next to the imperial interest in centralisation, it was unclear who, among the proposed honorary positions, should make the decisions, be responsible, and perform the actual work.

 

CATEGORICAL INEVITABILITY

[xiv]

The start of World War I in 1914 brought about significant changes in Tsarist Russian politics, including the closure of German schools and organisations. As a result, the former Baltic German elite was forced to step back from all aspects of life, including heritage conservation and the development of national organisations.


Through the collective action of the National Awakening, with the gradual gaining of dominance in rural and urban governments, and the practice of democracy and governance at Maapäev, Estonians created their own country on 24 February 1918. In the manifesto to the people of Estonia, there is a call to build homes where there is law and order, because this is required of us by the sweat and blood of our ancestors, who poured it for this land, and by future generations, who obligate us to do so.


The expressions of our ancestors' blood and sweat were, for many people, definitely antiquities in the landscape, as well as in folk art, handicrafts, tools, and utensils, among other things, from different time periods. The young country’s government established a department of art and heritage conservation within the Ministry of Education in February 1919, marking a significant step towards the organisation of museums and the preservation of heritage. Its leader became the artist Kristjan Raud. During the War of Independence, he continued to manage the work of the art conservation committees. However, by the autumn of the same year, the first draft of the Heritage Conservation Act was completed, modelled after the Swedish law of 1867. In K. Raua’s assessment the preservation of ancient remains had to be the country’s priority, because only by knowing our antiquities and heritage, our people could grow into a nation that creates valuable culture: “From the perspective of general human culture the existence of our nation is only as important as much originality it can add to the treasure trove of universal human culture. Our country’s existence is justified solely because of our unique culture. First to ourselves and then to Europe!” [xv]


Karl August Hindrey’s (Hoia Ronk) drawing of Kristjan Raud.

ETMM 8239 T 2:1/34:7


The law provided for both closed and open inheritance, meaning the organisation of protection for archaeology, buildings, archives, museums, and church property, which is why K. Raud asked several people and organisations with expertise in various fields for their opinions on the draft. In the spring of 1920, the text was translated into German and sent to archaeologist Aarne Michaël Tallgren, soon to be a professor at the University of Tartu, who prepared a new draft rather than offering editorial suggestions. There were not many substantive changes, as Tallgren also based it on Swedish and Finnish laws.


Portrait of Professor Aarne Michaël Tallgren.

Photographer unknown.

ERM Fk 3076:406

 

FROM DRAFT TO LAW - ACCEPTANCE OF INHERITANCE

The draft was finalised in 1923 in the heritage administration of the Ministry of Education under the direction of Kristjan Raud, with the participation of ethnographers (archaeologists, historians, and art historians) and, later, also lawyers. However, it did not reach parliament until 1925.


Why did everything take so long? Was it because education ministers, as well as governments, changed often at the beginning of the republic? When the first Antiquities Protection Act was finally passed, the twelfth minister was already at work. Or was the reason for the delay the little faith that the politicians had in the experts' assessment of the situation regarding the antiquities? In journalism, there have also been ironic articles about antiquities over the years. For example, writer Artur Adson criticised in Päevaleht the cultural policy of the Ministry of Education, where more money was allocated in the budget for science and antiquities than for the field of art:

“...the capital buried in antiques and heritage never carries the same percentage as sums given for the benefit of living art, creative talents and their production to the people. [...] Or do they really think that acquisition of an old clock as a cultural asset for 75 thousand marks is more productive than publishing the works of P. Südda or R. Tobias, or sending a more talented artist or writer abroad to study, learn and improve? And are the emotions that people get from observing the mentioned clock for five minutes (no more is needed) stronger than the emotions they get from concerts or musical works of Tobias and Südda, which was created by a newly-minted artist-writer with state funding?!” [xvi]

Hugo Raudsepp allegorically seconded that a few weeks later:

“The story is like this, that the independence of Estonia has started to interest our ancestors and forefathers seriously. They have deemed it good to rise from the dead. [...] Our executive power is in the hands of our ancestors, and dead souls reign over the living by an absolute majority. [...] Don't blame the randomness and imbalance of the art budget. It is an ideology and system.” [xvii]


In March 1925, the patience of the scientific organisations ran out, and a memorandum to the Minister of Education was published in the larger newspapers. [xviii] The representatives of The Learned Estonian Society, The Estonian National Museum, The Estonian Literary Society, The Academic Historical Society, The Academic Literary Society, the Institute of Art History at the University of Tartu, and the Cabinet of Archaeology at the University of Tartu cited numerous examples in their letter of the destruction of antiquities and historical buildings and the selling of objects of scientific value. The scientists asked the minister to “to exert all his influence so that the protection law, which has been in the works for several years, will be published this spring”, because “Destruction work is mainly done in spring and summer, ploughing, construction, etc. Renovations of churches and other buildings also usually take place in summer.”

The draft that the Ministry of Education had given to the Parliament in June of 1923, and which, after that, was commuted between the Education Committee and General Committee, finally made it to the great hall for the first reading on June 17 1925. While introducing the law, member of parliament Aleksander Jõeäär, as a representative of the general committee, noted: “This law is wide-ranging, similar to the one that has been accepted in France, Sweden, and Finland. The law extends not only to the assets of public institutions and companies, but also to assets owned by private individuals. The Minister of Education carries out protection with the assistance of the Heritage Council. The latter’s composition guarantees that relatively strict protective measures will not be used without need.” [xix]


With an apparent majority of votes, the state assembly members agreed that there would not be the three-day recess prescribed in the rules of procedure between the first and second readings. Before the summer holidays, legislators had a strong desire to adopt as many as 32 bills. The second reading took place on June 18th in the afternoon, under the leadership of Werner Richard Karl Hasselblatt, the rapporteur of the general committee, who reviewed all sections and made minor corrections. The third reading and adoption of the law took place in the morning session of June 19, as the 16th agenda item, between the Settlers' Building Loan Act and the Universal Postal Convention and Agreements Ratification Act, which was concluded in Stockholm in 1924.


For ten years (1925-1935), heritage conservation management was led by Assistant Minister of Education Gottlieb Ney and, later, by archaeologist-ethnographer Eerik Laid, who served as the first inspector of heritage protection. On September 26, 1925, the Heritage Council held its first meeting. Information about the meetings was regularly published in newspapers - not only to announce the upcoming meeting, but also to report on what had been discussed after it had taken place. By 1940, they had held 62 meetings, during which proposals were made to the minister to protect approximately 2,200 monuments, the distribution of restoration grants was directed, and other conservation management issues were discussed.

That is how our ancestors’ blood and sweat were elevated to a position of honour and passed on to future generations by the founders of our country.

***

Leaving it to other writings to dissect all the intervening years in the history of heritage conservation, I’ll note at the end of this story that in 2021, Estonia joined the Council of Europe Framework Convention on Cultural Heritage, adopted in 2005 in Faro. According to this, cultural heritage is a group of resources from the past that people define, regardless of ownership, as a reflection and expression of their constantly changing values, beliefs, knowledge, and traditions. It encompasses all environmental aspects resulting from interactions between people and their surroundings over time. However, the heritage community comprises people who value specific aspects of cultural heritage and wish to preserve them through a public action network, passing on this legacy to future generations.


Indeed, heritage is the legacy of previous generations to their descendants, and receiving it also entails taking responsibility for it.



[i]

Poste, Edward. 1904. Oxford. Institutes of Roman Law.

[ii]

Lang, V. 2018. Läänemeresoome tulemised. Muinasaja Teadus 28. Tartu Ülikooli kirjastus. 168–178, 193–226.

[iii]

Jonuks, T. 2022. Eesti muinasusundid. 194-197, 219.

[iv]

Kriiska, A., Lang, V., Mäesalu, A., Tvauri, A., Valk, H. 2020. Eesti ajalugu I. Eesti esiaeg. Tartu: Tartu Ülikooli ajaloo ja arheoloogia instituut. 168–169.

[v]

Tomassetti L: Bullarum diplomatum et privilegiorum sanctorum romanorum pontificum, 23 vols. Augusta Taurinorum: Franco, Fory, Dalmazzo. 1857–72. vol.. 4, 716–718.

[vi]

Mannoni C. Protecting antiquities in early modern Rome: the papal edicts as paradigms for the heritage safeguard in Europe [version 1; peer review: 2 approved]. Open Res Europe 2021, 1:48 (https://doi.org/10.12688/openreseurope.13539.1)

[vii]

Mannoni C. Protecting antiquities in early modern Rome: the papal edicts as paradigms for the heritage safeguard in Europe [version 1; peer review: 2 approved]. Open Res Europe 2021, 1:48 (https://doi.org/10.12688/openreseurope.13539.1)

[viii]

Rootsi kuninga 1666. aasta seaduse kohta saab lugeda juurde näiteks siit: Historical Perspective of Heritage Legislation. Balance between Laws and Values. International Conference, October 12–13, 2016, Niguliste Museum, Tallinn, Estonia. Conference proceedings.

[ix]

Leimus, I. 2025. Eesti esimesed numismaatilised leiud pärinevad Läänemaalt. - Läänemaa muuseumi toimetised, XXVII, lk 19-20.

[x]

Mellini atlast saab igaüks uurida Maa- ja Ruumiameti geoportaalis. Vt lähemalt Tartu Ülikooli uudis 25.04.2024: Mellini atlas jõudis Maa-ameti kaardiserverisse.

[xi]

Reiman, V. 1910. Jaan Jungi elulugu. – Muinasajateadus eestlaste maalt. III. Kohalised muinasaja kirjeldused Tallinnamaalt. Kogunud ja välja annud J. Jung. Eesti Kirjanduse Seltsi Toimetused. Neljas osa. Lk XVII.

[xii]

Pirang, H. 1932. Die gesetzliche Regelung der Denkmalpflege. – Arbeiten des zweiten baltischen Historikertages zu Reval 1912. Herausgegeben von der Estländischen Literärischen Gesellschaft zu Reval und der Gesellschaft für Geschichte und Altertumskunde zu Riga. Reval: Franz Kluge. S. 174-175

[xiii]

Provinzialrecht der Ostseegouvernements. Erster Theil: Behördenverfassung. St. Petersburg, 1845. Viite eest vastavatele paragrahvidele avaldan tänu Toomas Hiiole.

[xiv]

Kristjan Raud kutsus artiklis „Kategooriline paratamatus“ üles muuseumidesse koguma ja sellega hävingust päästma rahvakunsti ja eluolu kirjeldavat pärandvara. Üleskutse ilmus esimesena 16. veebruaril 1920 ajalehes „Sakala“ - https://dea.digar.ee/article/sakalaew/1920/02/16/11

[xv]

1920. või 1921. aastal Kristjan Raual kirja pandud selgituskiri muinsuskaitsekorralduse prioriteetide ja olukorra kohta, tõenäoliselt suunatud lugemiseks ministeeriumi ülemustele. ERA.1108.5.35 lehed 81–83

[xvi]

Adson, A. Haridusministeeriumi kunstipoliitika. – Päevaleht, nr 78, 23. märts 1921, lk 2.

[xvii]

Milli Mallikas. Kodukäijatest, sõnnikuveost, ja kõrgemast koolmeistrist. – Vaba Maa, nr 93, 94, 12. – 13. aprill 1921

[xviii]

Meie vanaaja mälestusmärgid suures hädaohus. Kaja, nr. 82, 26 märts 1925 tr. 1 - https://dea.digar.ee/article/kaja/1925/03/26/1/37; Muinasvarade kaitseks. Postimees (1886-1944), nr. 89, 31 märts 1925 - https://dea.digar.ee/article/postimeesew/1925/03/31/17

[xix]

II Riigikogu 8. istungjärk. Protokoll nr. 247 (30). 1925. a. Lk 1405.

Read Ulla’s earlier reflection